GEO’s bias

This page was put up back in the good ol’ days when former President Pervez Musharraf initiated temporary Emergency Rule in Pakistan in November 2007. During this period, the media, which won its freedom only thanks to Musharraf, went wild and began a hate campaign against Musharraf. GEO, in particular, crossed all limits and, as a result, a number of channels were temporarily suspended in Pakistan.

GEO still continues its Musharrafphobia campaign. Its leading anchor, the bigot Hamid Mir, revealed his personal hate and contempt towards Musharraf to one of this blogs regular commentator, Sajjad Riaz, in an email as follows:

++++++++++++++++++

RE: MUSHARRAF THE BEST‏
From: Hamid Mir (hamid.mir@geo.tv)
Sent: 23 August 2008 14:08:55
To: sajjad riaz (*****)

I got job 21 years ago.Allah gave me job not Musharraf.

Musharraf nenver gave us license we were operating from Dubai.

Musharraf treated us like animals.He attacked us inside our offices,he used police against us on the roads,he tried to bribe us.He is not exposed yet but we will expose him soon.

++++++++++++++++++

Right here Hamid Mir has exposed the fact that he is by no means balanced and fair in his analysis and programmes. He has a personal grudge against Musharraf.

Not only that, he proves that he is a liar. Geo’s license can be seen on the PEMRA website. If GEO had no license, then how did some members of the police manage to trash their office in Islamabad in 2007? Oh my, GEO was running an office in Islamabad without a license? :)

His second lie is the claim that Musharraf attempted to “bribe” him. Instead, it is more reasonable that Mir is angry because Musharraf did not bribe him!

Just look at the way this guy writes…like a typical uneducated individual lacking all nuance and possessing a low IQ.

Police in Pakistan has always been corrupt and they have launched such attacks at all times, be it during the Bhutto and Nawaz regimes and all other regimes. Yes, there is a serious problem with our police. This is nothing new. But to blame Musharraf for it and to convey the impression as if he personally ordered the attack, rolled up his sleeves, designed the attack plan and oversaw its execution is to be extremely deceptive and dishonest. To correct Mir, some members of the police acted on their own authority without receiving any “orders” from members of the government, let alone from Musharraf.

As for Musharraf “treated us like animals“, then that is another example of gross disinformation and propaganda. Granted, things were not perfect, but let’s face it: Pakistan saw unprecedented freedom of expression under Musharraf. In a short span of time dozens and dozens of private channels opened up, often openly criticising Musharraf, with generally no action taken against them by the Musharraf government. This was unimaginable under the previous Nawaz and Bhutto regimes. Far from treating the likes of Mir “like animals”, the Musharraf era brought about unprecedented freedom within Pakistan.

Far from ever “exposing” Musharraf, Mir successfully managed to expose himself as an incoherent bigot in his above email rantings.

Of course, GEO’s anti-Musharraf propaganda campaign continues unabated. This destroys their claim of being balanced. They have proven to be only as “fair and balanced” as Fox News.

Here you are free to express your views and opinions against the propaganda campaign of GEO.

+++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++

The following was written back in the days of the temporary Emergency in 2007. I have decided to retain this text.

******************

GEO TV has set up a blog here where you can submit your supportive (and unsupportive/critical?) comments.

With very, very few exceptions, the negative comments, even if highly polite and decent, are not approved by the moderators of the GEO blog. I have been sent comments by some surfers which were written very politely and submitted to the GEO blog a long time ago which have yet to appear since they have been (presumably) rejected.

GEO boasts a lot about its ‘fair’ and ‘balanced’ coverage. But do not be fooled by their rhetoric. They do have an agenda. GEO is only interested in displaying opinions they agree with, whilst largely ignoring the opposing viewpoints. In this way GEO gives a very one sided presentation. Note also GEO’s clear cut refusal recently to cover the pro-Musharraf rally in Toronto. When approached and requested to give some coverage, GEO officials said that they are ordered only to cover anti-Musharraf rallies. So much for GEO’s claim of being ‘truthful’.

In light of this, I decided to allow people to post their critical comments and reservations concerning GEO’s overly biased, unfair and unnecessarily confrontational coverage of events from day one of the emergency.

Feel free to send your comments here and just remember not to be insultive and abusive. We have to maintain a higher character than the one displayed by GEO and the anti-Musharraf forces.

[Note:- let me make it clearer since some people obviously are having a difficulty following the above comments: irrelevant comments will not be accepted in this section. This section is reserved for those who wish to express an opinion against GEO's biased programming. If you wish to make supportive comments about GEO, then kindly post them on GEO's blog. If you wish to talk about issues having nothing to do with GEO's bias, then kindly post those comments at some appropriate location in the blog (not here).

But I guarantee you that despite this very clear, explicit and categorical request, some will still post irrelevant comments in this section! :) Don't try since they will not be approved].

Responses

  1. NAWAZ MET OSAMA FIVE TIMES :( below is borrowed from RUPPEE NEWS)

    ISLAMABAD: Former Pakistan prime minister Nawaz Sharif has met al-Qaida chief Osama bin Laden five times, says a former official of Pakistan’s Inter

    Services Intelligence (ISI), a claim hotly denied by Sharif’s Pakistan Muslim League-Nawaz (PML-N).

    Speaking in ARY news programme “Eleventh Hour”, the former ISI official and now chairman Defence of Human Rights organisation Khalid Khwaja claimed he had arranged meetings between bin Laden and Nawaz Sharif on bin Laden’s request and the Pakistan Muslim League-Nawaz (PML-N) chief had held five meetings with the al-Qaida chief so far.

    “I challenge the deniers of such meetings and can present solid evidences in this respect,” Khwaja was quoted as saying by ARY News on Wednesday.

    He said hopefully Nawaz Sharif would not “tell a lie” in this regard.

    He said he had met the al-Qaida chief more than a hundred times “but not after the 9/11 incident”.

    However, Pakistan Muslim League-Nawaz has termed the claims of the head of Defence of Human Rights organisation as baseless.

    The claims by Khalid Khwaja regarding the meetings between Nawaz Nawaz “>Sharif and Osama bin Laden were “meaningless”, the party’s information secretary Ahsan Iqbal told ARY news. Nawaz Sharif met Osama five times: Ex-ISI official IANS 9 September 2009, 12:26pm IST

    ISLAMABAD: Pakistan President Asif Ali Zardari has said that al-Qaida chief Osama bin Laden is dead, but has sought more international aid to expand

    military operations against Taliban, in areas where Americans believe he may be hiding.

    Asserting that his government was fighting the militants with determination, Zardari said these efforts were hampered by what he called lack of resources.

    In an interview to BBC to mark his first year in office as President, Zardari’s main emphasis was on Pakistan’s ailing economy and to make a pitch for much more enhanced assistance from the West.

    “If the world’s armies and the world’s budgets cannot look after (the Afghan) side of the border, give me more time and give me the resources that I need and we will deliver,” he said.

    He was replying to questions when Pakistan would act against Taliban militants based on its soil who carried out cross-border attacks against foreign troops in Afghanistan.

    On Osama, Pakistan President, however, did not put forward any evidence or details in support of his claim that world’s most wanted terrorist was no longer alive. Even earlier Zardari had put forward the same claim, which was not accepted by Washington.

    His remarks on Osama being dead run contrary to American belief that al-Qaida chief is alive and is hiding in Pakistan’s restive tribal areas bordering Afghanistan. Zardari claims Osama bin Laden is dead PTI 10 September 2009, 12:34pm IST.

  2. Nawaz Sharif is accused of Murder of an army officer in nineties in case of bribing Fata parlimentarians.Details on ZEE NEWS website.This is the time to judje supreme court so called Free. visit

    http://www.zeenews/news562617.html

  3. the general (retd),was the best thing that happened to pakistan since mr bhutto…
    i think that says it all….
    make your own party we will support….and many other people like us will….

  4. The day is not far away when the people of pakistan begging to Sir. Musherraf to rescue them from Mr.10% & Ganja Brothers.

  5. Q: Whats the only difference between MIR Jaffer,MIR Sadiq and HAMEED MIR?

    Ans: The word “MIR” comes first before their names.

  6. Reading the link by ehsanali , it became so clear that Nawaz Sharif, at least, involved in the bribery in the democracy, as confirmed by the court. And I am 100% sure most of our journalist have the knowledge about it. Including the Hamid Mir, Ansar Abbasi Irfan Siddiqui. But they never spoke a word about it. I haven’t heard any discussion about it or the case on any channel. This is a 100% proof that all these journalists and so called intellectuals are Munafiqs and they have no interest in democracy. They are dishonest. And sadly present time of Pakistan is in the hands of these people. The fate of Pakistan is obvious unless and until these sort of people manipulate the fate of Pakistan.

  7. I am so impressed with teh persistance of the Mush Supporters and would urge all and sundry to keep up their hopes alive and continue to contribute with theri efforts to protect teh name of the one-honest leader we wasted….
    Let not his name be tarnished by the hypocrites and the Mir Jafers

  8. May it be GEO or Hamid Mir, are one and the same thing. Both are biased and rhetoric about Musharraf. The Jang group and Hamid Mir and few other alikes are not honest and trying befooling the nation as they have their personal vendetta and do not have the capacity to face criticism on their foul plays. The Jang group being one of the leading channels wants the rulers of its choice and its owners have become greedy and think they are the only well wishers of Pakistan. Musharraf is not the type like goofy Nawaz or their favourites. Musharraf has the courage, vision and capacity to deal with such culprits in media or else where and that is why are afraid of Musharraf busy mud slinging all the times. Public is not naive, they knows their malafide intentions and time is approaching when they will find no place to hide their ugly faces. They are spoiling this nation but Allah Almighty knows how and when they should be brought to task. Musharraf is a hard nut to crack and nature is helping him despite their all abortive attempts to malign him.

  9. HOLD your horses guys….time is not very far when people will be begging for Musharraf to step in…….

  10. Please Must Read
    ….thought provoking!!

    Plz clear your mind and think

    I think you are not aware of GEO…its being funded by USA govt and India……just think what Jew /Indian/ American lobby want ……… the basic idea is to promote frustration, and despondence in a nation, so they start to demoralize and the future can be mapped as they want to project it in the minds of 50 percent illiterate population.. ..that are born Muslim, can’t read, but can see.
    Why on earth USA is concern with only GEO, why CNN, BBC and bush quote GEO? Why not other TV channels in china, japan, Cuba , India , Saudi Arabia , France ? Why only Pakistan ???? ??
    Why geo showed peoples’ bodies without head, only finger parts, people dying after bomb blast? Does any other channel show these things?
    Just think…… in India more than 2000 Muslims were killed in Gujarat in three months!!!! Did you see any 36 hours live coverage of these killings? Has any one seen this on ZEE or star or Sony etc… any Indian channel????
    Babri Masjid was destroyed by Hindus…. any live coverage???? Nuns in Tamil nado of India were burnt alive in a church and for next 6 hours the church kept burning. Did any Indian channel or CNN or BBC show that???? In France , 700 cars were burnt in one day… yet no coverage.
    There were 89 separatist movements in India in 2007 …from Bihar to Kashmir Assam etc … Did you see on any Indian channel showing 250 million people sleeping on footpath???? ?
    Zee India never showed killing of Kashmiris and the attack on GOLDEN TEMPLE , killing of Sikhs on Indian soil
    How many Israeli channels show killing by Israeli soldiers, when they kill Palestinians? ????
    Have you ever seen Indian president or politician being verbally abused on TV channels during live coverage????
    There have been reported 30,000 rape cases in USA … do you see on TV???? But you see Mukhtaran maee on geo/cnn/bbc
    Why geo was not concerned with Benazir’s wealth and property?? And Nawaz sharif’s property?
    WHO is GEO????
    Just think… they telecasted false news about emergency and hence the stock market crashed in Pakistan …

    Do you know Kamran Khan was getting RS 25 lakh per month?
    Do you know Dr. Shahid masood, was a member of NSF student party (a political left wing student party against Pakistan and Islamic forces…. with RS 22 lacs per month and home in dubai and Karachi
    Same amount been paid to Hamid Mir editor “Ausaf”……even Nadia Khan with Rs 6 lacs per month… Such huge amount, just to for free????
    When they were not able to broadcast the 8-hour cricket match, they said they lost 1 billion rupees, and just imagine without any money just for free they were broadcasting judge activity in peoples party car for free, Nawaz sharif and benazir for free……all 36 hour coverage just for free????? By a private channel!!!!! !
    50 percent Indian dramas on geo and 25 percent with mix cast (Indian and Pakistani) and Indian films.
    Movie like “khuda key liyaeh” an issue of religion, so that people can play with Islam and its culture was telecasted.
    Alim online where Mr. Amir Liaqat sitting in grave and dramatizing Islam. He translated the dua of imam kaba and broadcasted his name on TV…. Audience: 50% jahil people in pakistan
    geo did not show any good news like Islamabad Peshawar motorway but instead it showed dead people in karachi ….they never discuss 5.1 billion dollar of oil refinery in Pakistan, instead they show beheading of Pakistani people… never discuss why America is telling musharf to take off his uniform????/ why is USA interfering in our business!!!! !!!!!!!!! !!!!!!
    HAS ANYBODY [CRICKET LOVER] EVER WONDERED/NOTICED THAT GEO SUPER, WHICH CLAIMS TO BE THE SOLE LARGEST SPORTS CHANNEL OF PAKISTAN HAS NEVER EVER BROADCASTED ANY CRICKET MATCH OF PAKISTAN AND NOT EVEN HIGHLIGHTS BUT IT HAS ALWAYS BROADCASTED EVERY MATCH EVEN TEST MATCHES OF INDIA AND THESE DAYS IT ALL THE TIMES SHOWS THE ONGOING IPL WHILE A WHOLE SERIES OF PAKISTAN VS AUSTRALIA HAS JUST CONCLUDED AND GEO HAS REMAINED QUIET IN THIS MATTER!!
    IF YOU RECALL THE DAYS WHEN GEO WAS BANNED FOR A FEW DAYS, HOW PEACEFUL THOSE DAYS WERE!! AND EVEN EX-PRESIDENT MUSHARRAF HAD ONCE SAID THAT IF YOU COME TO KNOW ABOUT THE FUNDING-SOURCES OF GEO, YOU WILL SUPPORT ITS BANNING!
    Itna jhoot bolo, k log sumjhen kuch to succh ho ga …

    Prophet Muhammad (PBUH) said…Budd Gumanee nahin karna chahiye… and he also said that for a Muslim it is a lie if he states without any enquiry / investigation

  11. is there any way k ham in logoon i mean Hamid Mir, Talat Hussain, Kashif Abbasi, Asma Shirazi, Mazhar abbas or bolta pakistan k 2 cartoons jaisay logoon ko awaam k samnay nanga kar sakain k ye loog sirf aik khaas agenday par kaam karnay walay blackmalers hain jin ka kaam sirf larana or mazay laina hay or mostly ye loog nawaz sharif k payroll par kam kartay hain

  12. has anyone ever asked how did hamid mir buy a property in chuk shehzad, every body critisizes musharaf, musharaf was the chief of army staff and the president of pakistan & he also belongs to a well to do family. on the contrary hamid mir was just a cheap journalist who no one knew before he came on geo and all of a sudden he becomes so rich that he owns a farms house. he has been taking money from the indians and other enemy states to destabilize pakistan.

  13. nawaz shirif ( na bap sharif na maa sharif unka baata nawaz sharif) is the guy who master minded the lal masjid. he was behind it all. the idiot did nothin during his 10 years stay in saudia but to grow hair, if i find this idiot on the road by God i will kick him in his bottocks, this idiot has 11 sugar mills in india, he is a traitor, in paksitan he owns more than 10 sugar mills, and look at the sugar crisis, the idiot is also makin money like zardari.


Leave a response

Your response: