This is a continuation and an expansion of the previous essay entitled: Under Musharraf
The purpose of this essay is, once again, to bring to your attention the wide-scale economic development currently being witnessed by Pakistan as well as the numerous large scale projects being implemented throughout Pakistan under President Musharraf.
As noted before, these facts are hardly ever mentioned on our news channels. As a result, many individuals seriously believe that nothing positive is taking place in Pakistan, that nothing has been achieved under President Musharraf, and that all is dark and gloomy etc. In reality, however, we have never witnessed as much economic growth in the history of Pakistan as is currently taking place. Never have we witnessed so much investment in Pakistan. Never have we witnessed so much boom in the economic sector. By large, things are heading in the right direction and, overall, the country has seen a significant improvement in almost every sphere and department.
With only a few exceptions, references have been provided for all of the points at the end of this paper.
++++++++++++++++++++++
Musharraf Era performance: Pakistan Flourishes
Mirza Rohail Baig
This is all the more amazing when one considers that just five years ago, Pakistan was on the verge of bankruptcy, with only a little more than $1 billion in foreign exchange reserves, its stock market teetering at 1,000 points (worth $5 billion only) and foreign debt servicing at 65% of GDP.
The forex reserves now stand at over $16.5 billion. The once ever-declining rupee has been stable at around 60-61 to a dollar since Musharraf took over. Of the 184 member countries of the IMF, Pakistan’s rate of economic growth (7%) has been one of the best in the world. Moreover, the Karachi stock market is now above 13,000 points and worth around $65 billion. On top of that, foreign debt servicing has now decreased to 28%.
1. The Pakistan economy is among the fastest growing economies in the world, having reached the size of $160 billion from a mere $70 billion in 1999. Furthermore, Pakistan attracted a record investment of $6 billion last year.
2. 2007: National revenues had swelled from Rs 308 billion during 1988-99 to around a trillion in 2007 and the FBR now estimates 2.8 million income tax payers.
3. Public sector development program (PSDP) has grown from Rs 80 billion in 1999 to Rs 520 billion in 2007.
4. FACT: The rate of growth in Pakistan’s Large Scale Manufacturing (LSM) is at a 30-year high. Construction activity is at a 17-year high.
5. FACT: The Infrastructure Industries Index, which measures the performance of seven industries (i.e., Electricity generation, Natural gas, Crude oil, Petroleum products, Basic metal, Cement and coal) has recorded a 26.2 percent growth in the Industrial sector of Pakistan.
6. FACT: Jan 14: According to the National Education Census (NEC-2005), Pakistan now has a total of 245,682 Educational institutions in all categories, including 164,579 (i.e. 67%) in the public sector and 81,103 (i.e. 33%) in the private sector.
The census — jointly conducted by the Ministry of Education, the Academy of Educational Planning and Management (AEPAM) and the Federal Bureau of Statistics (FBS) — reveals that the number of private-sector institutions has increased from 36,096 in 1999-2000 to 81,103 in 2005, i.e. by 100%. Educational Institutions have increased by 45,007 in the Musharraf Era.
7. FACT: According to an IMF report, Pakistan is 3rd in Banking profitability in the world. On the IMF chart, Pakistan’s banking profitability is on third position after Colombia and Venezuela. On the same IMF chart, India is on the 36th position and China is on the 40th position.
8. FACT: According to a report entitled, “Doing Business in 2006,” co-sponsored by the World Bank and the International Finance Corporation (IFC), Pakistan globally ranks 10th among the countries most active in pursuing pro-business policies.
9. In 1999 what we earned as GDP: we used to give away 64.1% as foreign debt and liabilities. In 2006, what we earned as GDP: we gave ONLY 28.3% as foreign debt and liabilities. We are now SAVING 35% of our GDP for economic growth.
10. According to the Economic Survey 2005, poverty in Pakistan in 2001 was 34.46%. And now, after 7-8 years of Musharraf, poverty in 2005 was 23.9%. Thus, poverty DECREASED by 10.56%. Overall, 12 million people have been pushed out of Poverty in 2001 – 2005!
11. Literacy rate in Pakistan has increased from 45% (in 2002) to 53% (in 2005). Education now receives 4% of GDP and English has been introduced as a compulsory subject from grade 1.
12. 12-4-07: The IT industry, which was virtually non-existent seven years ago, has grown to be worth $2 billion of which $1 billion is export related. It registered a 50% growth. 55 foreign IT companies have already entered the market. Now the I.T. sector alone employs 90,000 professionals.
13. Nov 2006: President Musharraf said that Pakistan will set up Nine Engineering World Class Science and Technology Federal Universities by 2008 with foreign assistance. He said the institutions of higher learning would be established in collaboration with Italy, South Korea, Japan, France, Sweden, Netherlands, Germany, Austria and China. The Cost of building these Universities will be over Rs 96.5 billion.
The Vice Chancellors, Heads of department, Professors and Faculty of the planned university will be from these foreign Universities, while the examination system, the quality assurance followed, as well as the Degree awarded will also be from these foreign Universities.
14. The Government has approved to give at least 4% of GDP to Education in the 2007 budget.
15. In 1999-2000 there were 31 Public Universities. Now 2005-2006 there are 49 Public Universities.
-
Air University (established 2002); Institute of Space technology, ISB (established 2002); Sardar Bahadur Khan Women University, Quetta (established 2004); University of Science & Technology, Bannu (established 2005); University of Hazara (founded 2002); Malakand university, Chakdara (established 2002); Karakurum International university, Gilgit (established 2002); University of Gujrat (established 2004); Virtual University of Pakistan, Lahore (established 2002); Sarhad University of IT, Peshawar (established 2001); etc.
16. 6-member delegation of Australian Department of Education, Science & Technology and AusAID, visited Pakistan on the request of PM Shaukat Aziz in order to help Pakistan in its efforts to realign its TVET (Technical and Vocational Education and Training) according to the market needs. Chairman NAVTEC, Altaf Saleem, informed the delegation about NAVTEC plans to increase the capacity to train one million people annually by 2010 from the present annual capacity of 320,000.
17. Defense Exports of Pakistan have crossed the $200 million mark as the country’s robust Defense manufacturing industry continues to expand. This was disclosed by Major General Syed Absar Hussain, Director General, Defense Export Promotion Organization (“International Defence Exhibition and Seminar (IDEAS) 2006″ held at karachi.).
18. President Musharraf inaugurated an 18 Mega Watt Naltar hydro power project, of over Rs. 1.36 billion. The project was completed in four years at Naltar near Gilgit.
19. Pakistan is now in Large-scale Nuclear expansion. The reactor under construction could produce over 200kg of weapons-grade plutonium per year, assuming it operates at full power for a modest 220 days per year. At 4 to 5 kilograms of plutonium per weapon, this stock would allow the production of 40-50 Nuclear weapons a year.
20. The Karachi Port Trust (KPT) and Hutchison Port Holdings (HPH) of Hong Kong will sign a concession agreement for setting up a US$1 billion Deep-water container port, the first in Pakistan. KPT will invest $450 million for infrastructure development for the project. HPH will invest $557 million. In the first phase, a 1,500m quay wall will be built with a designed dept of 18m.
21. GILGIT: President Musharraf inaugurated the dry port in the border town of Sust, 200 km north of Gilgit. The Dry port, a Pakistan-China joint venture, was built in 2004 at a cost of Rs90 million, on a height of 10,000-foot.
22. Dec 2006: President Musharraf said that many canals, including the Thal and Raini canals, were being constructed for better utilization of the available water. He said Rs66 billion was being spent on the brick-lining of 87,000 canals in the country, adding that 6,000 new canals would be brick-lined next year.
23. The Private Power Infrastructure Board (PPIB) has approved expansion of Tarbela dam power project which would generate 960 MW costing $500 million.
24. President Musharraf recently inaugurated the Mirani Dam. Mirani Dam in Kech area of Mekran district, with a catchment area of 12,000 square kilometer, has been built in four years at a cost of Rs6 billion which includes Rs1.5 billion in compensation to the affected people. It will have a storage capacity of over 300,000 million acre feet of water.
25. Gomal Zam Dam: This project started in Aug 2002 and is expected to be completed in early 2008. It is located in the Damaan in NWFP. It is 437 feet high and will irrigate about 163,000 acres of land. The total costs amounts to Rs. 12 billion, with a gross storage of 1.14 MAF. It will produce 17.4 MW of electricity.
26. Mushrraf says the government is constructing the Katchi Canal, costing Rs40 billion, and that Punjab had been gracious to provide land for the 350 kilometer stretch which will pass through the province.
27. The Economic Coordination Committee decided to set up a $2-billion mega Oil refinery at Khalifa Point in district Hub, Balochistan. The refinery, commissioned by 2010, would have a maximum refining capacity of 13 million tons of petroleum products — higher than the country’s total existing capacity of 12.8 million tons.
28. Pakistan Steel Mills Corporation (PSMC) during the quarter July-Sept 2007 recorded the highest ever-sales figure of Rs 9.3012 billion.
29. The Compressed Natural Gas (CNG) sector of Pakistan has attracted over Rs 70 billion investments during the last five years as a result of liberal and encouraging policies of the government. Presently, some 1,765 CNG stations are operating in the country, in 85 cities and towns, and 1000 more would be set-up in the next three years. It has provided employment for 30,000 people in the country.
30. The Securities and Exchange Commission of Pakistan (SECP) has registered 1,135 companies during the first quarter (July-September 2007). With the new registrations the total number of registered companies with SECP as of September 30 reached 50,125.
31. Telecom sector has attracted an investment of $ 9 billion in the last three years. It alone created 80,000 jobs directly and 500,000 jobs indirectly.
32. Former corrupt and incompetent Prime Minister, Nawaz Sharif, made only one motorway – M2 (Lahore – Islamabad). Under Musharraf 6 motorways are either completed or under construction:
-
•M1 (Islamabad to Peshawar) – (Rs.13 bn) – [155 km] – (started 2003 – Completed Oct 2007)
•M3 (Pindi to Faisalabad) – (Rs.5.6 bn) – [53 km] – (started 2002 – Completed 2004)
•M8 (Gwadar to Ratodero) – [1072 km] – (started 2004 – will complete 2009)
•M9 (Karachi to Hyderabad) – (Rs.6.3 bn) – [136 km]
•M10 (Karachi Northern bypass) – (Rs 3.5 bn) – [56 km] – (completed 2007)
•M11 (Lahore to Sialkot) – (Rs.23 bn) –[101 km] – (started 2006 – under construction)
33. Under Musharraf various highways under construction throughout the country. Including N5, N-25, N-35, N-45, N-50, N-55, N-65, N-70, N-75, N-80, S-1, etc.
34. General Pervez Musharraf inaugurated the Makran Coastal Highway (N-10) project in August 2001, consisting of Karachi-Gwadar, Pasni-Gwadar, and Ormara-Liari (Balochistan) Highways. The cost of the Liari-Ormara Highway was Rs3.9 billion and that of Pasni-Gwadar Highway, Rs2.8 billion respectively. The total length of Makran Coastal Highway is 533 kilometers.
35. 2-12-07: Sialkot International Airport Limited (SIAL) completed. The 1,002-acre airport is 13 km west of Sialkot and is linked by a road to Gujranwala, Wazirabad, Gujrat, Narowal, the Export Processing Zone (EPZ) and the Sialkot Dry Port Trust.
36. Ghandara International Airport (Islamabad) the first-ever green-field airport being built at a cost of $400 million; with a renowned international consultant, Louis Berger Group of USA. President Musharraf laid the foundation stone of the project on April 7, 2007. It will be completed by Dec 2010. Its total area is 3700 acres (15 km²).
37. Major Industrial estates are being developed under Musharraf’s vision: M3 industrial, Sundar industrial estate, Chakri industrial, etc.
38. Oct 2007: In the current fiscal year the Mining and Quarrying sector has registered a growth rate of 5.6 percent. Increased growth was propelled by strong growths recorded in magnetite (30 percent), dolomite (26.1 percent), Limestone (25.2 percent) and chromites.
39. The government has already started various initiatives, to discover and develop world-class copper-gold deposits in Chagai Baluchistan by Australian Firms which would fetch $500 million to $600 million per year.
40. Major reserves of COPPER & GOLD in Baluchistan’s Rekodiq area were discovered in early 2006. It has ranked Rekodiq among the world’s top seven copper reserves. The Rekodiq mining area has proven estimated reserves of 2 billion tons of copper and 20 million ounces of gold. According to the current market price, the value of the deposits has been estimated at about $65 billion, which would generate thousands of jobs.
41. Executive Committee of National Economic Council (ECNEC) recently approved 45 developmental projects in its meeting, including six revised projects, with a total cost of Rs 154.1 billion and with a foreign exchange component (FEC) of Rs 36.8 billion.
42. Rs 9.8 billion have been allocated for 91 different mega projects at Public Sector Universities across the province, said Sindh Governor Dr. Ishrat-ul-Ebad Khan.
43. Oct 2007: A fully functional TMS (Tax Management System), including profiling, withholding, return/payment filing, rectification, refunds, audit, and legal tracking is scheduled to be operational by 2007 in Pakistan, to process the tax year 2007 returns, according to World Bank.
44. The government is providing Sui Gas facility to areas of South Punjab at a cost of Rs 1.311 billion. A total of 1,138 kilometre gas pipeline is being laid. The districts benefiting from these schemes mainly include Multan, Khanewal, Bahawalnagar, Rajanpur, DG Khan, Vehari and Muzaffargarh.
45. The Karachi city government’s rehabilitation of Industrial zones and improvement plan for all four industrial zones of the city needs to be completed in 7-8 months. The projects are worth Rs 2.5 billion whereas the ‘beautification’ project worth Rs 4.5 billion.
46. 27-11-07: Pakistan Navy Ship Zarrar, the first of Multi-Role Tactical Platform (MRTP-33), was commissioned into Pakistan Navy at a ceremony at PN Dockyard.
47. 29-12-07: City Nazim Mustafa Kamal said the construction work of a 47-storey IT Tower in the vicinity of Civic Centre at a cost of $200m would start soon. Around 40,000 youth would get employment in the IT Tower. It will have 10,000 call centres, out of which 6,000 have already been booked so far.
48. The President approved the project of laying of 940-kilometre-long “standard gauge” Railway track between Gwadar and Quetta, with a cost of Rs 75 billion. A German firm won the contract.
49. To increase the income of farmers, the Government is investing Rs7.80 billion, under which a “Food Security Program” will be launched. Initially, it will be launched in 1,000 villages. The President said that Rs 3.60 billion would be invested in live-stocks and dairy sectors. About 1,200 model dairy farms and 2,950 cattle breeding farms will be established under this investment project.
50. Pakistan will launch a Self-controlled Remote Sensing Satellite System (RSSS), at a cost of Rs19.3 billion, to ensure strategic and unconditional supply of satellite remote sensing data for any part of the globe over the year. SUPARCO will implement it over a period of six years. President Musharraf has approved the project in principle.
51. The Governor of Sindh, Dr Ishrat-ul-Ebad Khan, inaugurated the DUHS Medical Research City with Dow Diagnostic Reference and Research Laboratories and Jinnah Genome Centre as its important components. He also laid the foundation stone for a library and sports complex which houses different constituent institutions of the university.
52. President Musharraf inaugurated a 50-bed state-of-the-art Workers Welfare Fund Kidney Centre. The first-ever kidney centre in Baluchistan, constructed on 7.5 acres, at a cost of Rs385 million, and having the diagnostic, dialysis, surgical and lab facilities, will help the people of this area.
53. Karachi: The building of the 50-bed Kidney Centre in Landhi has been completed. Minister Muhammad Adil Siddiqui said that the building of this centre had been built at a cost of Rs70 million.
54. CM Pervaiz Elahi inaugurated Pakistan’s first Software technology park (STP) on Ferozpur Road, to be implemented by Punjab IT Board (PITB). The Rs 1.5 billion project is set over an area of 32 kanals; will be completed in 12 months and is expected to directly create 10,000 jobs and generate economic activity of Rs 9 billion per year.
55. In what is considered a major leap for Pakistan, a Polytechnic Institute is being established to produce skilled workforce that will rescue the manufacturing industry from the clutches of foreign dependence. Being built in Korangi at a cost of Rs450 million, this government-funded institute will start operating in January 2007 and prepare 500 workers by the end of the first year, besides producing 22 different types of dies and moulds for aviation, telecom, pharmaceutical and other industries. Experts from Germany, Japan and Thailand assisted in developing its curriculum.
56. Police Act 1861 replaced by Police Order 2002 after 141 years. Police force divided into three separate wings: Watch and ward, Investigation and Prosecution.
57. Federal Minister for Commerce, in order to modernize tobacco farming in the country, is setting up a state-of-the-art Tobacco Research Centre in Bunner. Annually 8 million kilograms of Virginia tobacco (fine quality), worth Rs 9.2 billion is cultivated in Bunner. Under construction.
See also:
- Musharraf Era: Ushers in Multi-Nationals Corporations & booms Private sector Business
- Under Musharraf
- ECONOMIC GROWTH IN PAKISTAN
- Post-Musharraf scenario please . . .
References
1. Source
2. Revenues
3. PSDP
4. n/a
7. Banking
8. Business
9. n/a
10. Poverty
11. n/a
12. IT
13. 9 Uni
14. n/a
15. Uni HEC
16. Navtec
17. Defense exports
18. Naltar
19. Nuclear
20. Deep port
21. Sust Port
23. Tarbela
24. Mirani
25. Gomal Zam
26. Katchi canal
27. n/a
28. Steel Mills
29. CNG
30. SECP
31. Telecom
32. Motorways
33. Highways
34. Makran coastal
35. Sialkot Airport
36. Ghandara Airport
37. M3
39. Chagai
40. Rekodiq
41. ECNEC
42. Public Uni
43. n/a
44. Sui
45. Source
46. Zarrar
47. IT Tower
48. Railway track
49. Farms
50. RSSS
51. DUHS
52. Kidney
53. n/a
54. IT park
55. n/a
56. Police Act
57. Bunner
++++++++
© Musharraf Supporters 2008 All rights reserved
Assalam Alaikum Saad,
Glad to know you like the site. Inshallah we will continue to add more material here. Please do keep visiting the site and keep us all in your duas.
By: uss017 on April 7, 2008
at 5:16 pm
Hats off to your effort. A tribute to our great leader.
Pakistan Zindabad.
By: Jameel Mohammad on April 29, 2008
at 11:44 am
Jeevay Pakistan – Long life to President Musharraff
By: Afzal Sadi on May 14, 2008
at 7:11 am
Thanks for keeping this website.
At least it is going to remind our fellow Pakistani’s how much progress we did under our General.
By: Misbah Saleem Mohammad Khan on May 14, 2008
at 7:13 am
It is sickening when you hear our local & regional leaders lie to us about the work of President Musharaff.
As a Omani Baluch we do not realize to note that really in the past several years Pakistan has prospered.
The question remains .. will all this information be told and present to poor uneducated Pakistani’s who do not even know to sign their own name !
By: Rehmat Ihrahim Al Balouchi on May 19, 2008
at 1:33 pm
http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=GZ4GIfEk9NQ
Long Live Musharraf Video 60 sec of shock and awe for the fans of retarded judges
By: Jaf on June 9, 2008
at 3:36 am
ehhe econ boom, that’s why devaluation of Ruppee and inflation got increased every year. Why don’t you publish the SBP report which has been indicating about severe inflation and loss of reserves during Mush/Shauky era.
Or its just you guys love to live in dream world?
By: Adnan Siddiqi on June 14, 2008
at 3:41 pm
Adnan,
You’re factually wrong in most of your assertions. But first, even if, for arguments sake, we suppose that you are right, that in no way negates the facts mentioned in this paper. In order to deny the above facts, you need to deal with them directly and explain why we are allegedly wrong in mentioning them instead of dragging in red-herrings. Thus, by mentioning the alleged instability of the rupee, the high inflation, the alleged loss of reserves, NOTHING listed above has been ‘disproved’ by you.
Now to your false statements:
1. Rupee was broadly stable under Musharraf and Shaukat Aziz. It did not wildly fluctuate and devalue as it has within 3 months of the new government’s coming to power. For example, according to this recent sbp report:
“Pak rupee after remaining stable for more than four years, lost significant value against the US dollar depreciating by 13.4 percent during Jul-21st May 2008.”
Note carefully the part: …AFTER REMAINING STABLE FOR MORE THAN FOUR YEARS…
According to the various sbp reports:
A) “The Rupee has remained stable … ” (source)
B) “While the initial years of reforms did see sharp depreciation of the rupee, with the emergence of macroeconomic stability, Pakistan has enjoyed a degree of exchange rate stability, which has augured well for restoring investor confidence.” (Source)
C) “. . . a stable exchange rate gave the needed impetus to maintain and enhance competitiveness” (source)
D) “… and stable exchange rate suggest that financial sector vulnerability has decreased significantly as a result of broad-based improvement in the economy.” (Source)
E) “When the reserves began to accumulating even more rapidly, exchange rate became stable …” (source)
F) “Interest rates were already on the way down; foreign currency reserves were edging up; the exchange rate was relatively stable … ” (Source)
G) “Exchange rate has been stable but allowed to free float …” (source)
The above are a few examples I came across while searching the sbp website.
2.Foreign reserves of Pakistan in 1999 were $700 million. Under Musharraf and Shaukat Aziz foreign reserves in 2007 were over $15 billion – THE HIGHEST IN PAKISTAN’S HISTORY (i.e. Foreign Reserves grew by around 500%) [Reference]. According to this sbp report, Pakistan’s foreign reserves stood at $15.6 billion by June 2007. According to the same report, Pakistan’s foreign reserves “reached a historical peak of US$ 16.5 billion.” Compare this with the ‘performance’ of the new government: within 3 months Pakistan foreign reserves have plummeted down to around $11 billion! (see sbp report here)
The sbp website CONFIRMS the growth of foreign reserves under President Musharraf (for example, see this as well).
Consider this historically too: according to another sbp paper, Pakistan’s foreign reserves had risen up to $3.2 billion by September 10 2001. To quote from this paper:
“In 1999, the ratio of foreign reserves held by India was 40 times that of Pakistan. By June 2002 this ratio has declined to 8 times while the size of Indian economy is about 6 to 7 times that of Pakistan.”
In the language of an idiot, this means that Pakistan’s foreign reserves were steadily increasing.
Another quote from the same paper:
“It may be relevant to point out that the biggest quantum jump in our reserves had taken place between July 2000 and June 2001 i.e. well before September 2001. During this one year period the reserves increased by 138 percent to $ 3.1 billion. The rate of increase during July 2001 and June 2002 was 105 percent.”
Conclusion: the various sbp papers give a lie to your assertion about foreign reserves.
3. Inflation is a global phenomenon. Pakistan cannot be insulated from its ill effects. No matter what regime was in power, inflation would have still occurred.
In light of the above and the fact you do not appear to have the ability to comprehend the sbp reports, we can safely conclude that you ARE dwelling in a dream world.
By: uss017 on June 15, 2008
at 12:11 am
My darling if your MUSH did so wel, why did Paksitan suffer more than ever? Why did so called trickle down effect didn’t bring any betterment among common Pakistanis. Now don’t come with examples which lame and ignorant mush gave many times tht there are so many CARS now, so many mobiles etc because such examples r nothing but laughing stock for economists.
By: Adnan Siddiqi on June 15, 2008
at 5:59 am
Adnan, first let me make it clear to you that I am not your “darling.” You need to learn to express yourself in a courteous manner, write/speak with etiquettes when having a discussion with others and avoid applying cheap terminology.
Secondly, you literally ignored EVERYTHING I said. For example, I began by explaining why your comments were irrelevant. You said nothing in response. I then DISPROVED your assertions by citing your own named source: the sbp. I showed the sbp said the complete opposite of your claims. Your reply? Absolutely nothing. You did not even apologise for giving disinformation. Instead, you’ve now introduced unrelated and irrelevant subjects to the original discussion. How will you react if I again offer a point by point response to your new claims? Will you next drag in the lal-masjid episode as a ‘response’? Needless to say, these are very poor argumentation techniques.
Again let us suppose that you’re absolutely right about the weakness of the “trickle down effect” hypothesis and that common Pakistanis felt no betterment in their lifestyle etc. Well, THAT STILL LEAVES YOUR EARLIER ASSERTIONS TO BE BLATANTLY FALSE. Your new claims fail to transform your previous misleading assertions into the truth. What you said before still remains false. I hope you are getting this.
To briefly respond to your new claims: I don’t know why anyone, particular a qualified economist, would “laugh” if we were to consider the production and sales of cars, mobiles, electronic appliances in general etc. Why is it “ignorant” and “laughable” to consider such figures when they are taken into account by all nations? But yes, I can see why people would laugh if someone were to make claims by referring to a source (sbp for example) even though the source said the opposite
Putting aside the validity of the trickle down hypothesis, I would say that under Musharraf we have seen immense betterment to the lifestyle of many millions of common Pakistanis. All my friends, family, and people I know in general living all over Pakistan, including villages in Punjab and rural areas etc., particularly the young university graduates, are generally doing much better under Musharraf. But true, many millions are not doing well and there remains a lot of poverty in Pakistan. What did you expect? Things do not improve instantly. It requires time. On the whole, there has been much betterment for the common man under Musharraf. We have strived to prove here, with evidence, that under Musharraf Pakistan has thrived more than ever, with a booming and resilient economy (which is now being destroyed by looter politicians).
By: uss017 on June 15, 2008
at 10:32 pm
Putting aside the validity of the trickle down hypothesis, I would say that under Musharraf we have seen immense betterment to the lifestyle of many millions of common Pakistanis. All my friends, family, and people I know in general living all over Pakistan, including villages in Punjab and rural areas etc., particularly the young university graduates, are generally doing much better under Musharraf. But true, many millions are not doing well and there remains a lot of poverty in Pakistan. What did you expect? Things do not improve instantly. It requires time. On the whole, there has been much betterment for the common man under Musharraf. We have strived to prove here, with evidence, that under Musharraf Pakistan has thrived more than ever, with a booming and resilient economy (which is now being destroyed by looter politicians).
————————–
USS : Very good coverage of act, we are full of complaints, when you see poor people of Cambodia, Philippines, Indonesia, India, Sri Lanka … who due to poverty are ready to even sell their daughters for a night stand .. than you realise that we are not as poor as we claim.
It is surprising that people say they are poor in Pakistan but still are able to afford properties ownership which is minimum at times valued at 1 crore.
People should admit this fact that contrary to all claims the standard of living of middle class Pakistani’s have grown under the rule of Gen. Musharaff.
By: Mustafa Shabbir on July 7, 2008
at 5:15 am
The propaganda about poverty and high price is a universal slogan for any opposition in order to bring unrest against the government and win the hearts of masses. We all know that poverty and high price are relative terms. A country like Pakistan can not easily jump to the row of developed country. So these poverty and high price only produce frustration and dissatisfaction in the country. The trap PML-N and PPP and other opposition parties and media set for the previous government , in this trap the present government has being trapped in its infancy. Pakistan started off near about from zero in 1947 and slowly it has been progressing. Some government has do much better than others like you mentioned during Pres. Musharaf and also during Ayub Khan regime. In order to speak about development of a particular government it is utmost essential that we must have a complete comparisons of the previous government and also the countries in our neighborhood . For example when people say the flour prices have go sky high we are forgetting the prices in our neighboring countries. In fact, the major problem we faced for the flour unavailability was that our wheat prices were least perhaps in the world and naturally due to our porous borders wheat got smuggled up to central Asian countries. The Pakistani media role has been very immature and destructive. On one hand they have been surviving on advertisements and so causing more money spent on luxury items and reducing our savings but in return what they deliver to the common people just enhancing their frustration and restlessness. The media all over the world is supposed to help people to improve their lives and give them actual facts and figures but our media gave our people cries and frustration.
I hope Mr. Baig would do a little more research and tell the development of economy during the past governments as well.
By: Tariq M Khan on July 9, 2008
at 5:57 am
Great job Rohail and thank you for giving us so much information.Thank you for highlighting all that has been achieved in the presidents term.Hope we all learn from our mistakes including the MEDIA and learn to behave with more resposibility.Lets pray that president musharraf stays on doing all the good which was going to bear fruit had it not been severed .Long live pakistan and be blessed always with leaders of integrity and vision like our president.Long live writers who bring the truth to be seen .
By: rabia Haq on July 15, 2008
at 11:45 am
Tariq Khan has quite correct covered the problems of inflation & politics in the Third world countries !
By: Mustafa Shabbir on August 2, 2008
at 6:53 am
[...] 2. Musharraf Era performance: Pakistan Flourishes [...]
By: A Tribute to My President « Musharraf Supporters on August 19, 2008
at 6:46 pm
18.8.2008 was a Sad day for all of us.
May Allah take care of us after the loss of our great leader.
By: M. Khan on August 20, 2008
at 7:48 am
Dear don’t support any general because of them we lost a part of Pakistan (Bangladesh) and this figures are economical booms which never last for long time and be realistic.
++++++++
[Moderator's response: Assalam Alaikum Khadim. I think it is unfair to solely blame "the general" for the break-up of Pakistan in 1971. Politicians were also involved in the tragedy. The main culprits behind Pakistan's break-up were Zulfikar Ali Bhutto and Sheikh Mujibur Rahman. Army also gets the blame. But to put all blame upon them alone is unfair and historical revisionism.
As for the figures of economic achievements under Musharraf, we have cited the references and they are facts whether one likes it or not. As for them not "lasting long", then no achievement can last long if people make a mess of things. Nawaz Sharif and Zardari are experts at destroying our achievements.]
By: Khadim Hussain on August 21, 2008
at 3:41 am
Mr.Khadim Hussain
The problem of us the Pakistani People is we block out rest of the world and its influence on us.
We are not independent ,Pakistani Journalists ,writers and poets must stop living in four walls of Pakistan,it is like we are individuals we are free but as soon as our behaviour becomes an annoyance to our neighbours,family members or members of society we are told to restrain or bear consequences.
People of Pakistan must understand,Pakistan is an independent state but it has responsibilities and a role to play in International politics.We cannot survive without that.
We are so anti American so anti Army ,it is not army or it is not America which stopped our Chief of staff to land in Pakistan.If America couldnot stop us from having a nuclear bomb and declaring one what hold have they got on us?
Somethings we need to read very deeply before we draw conclusions.
Nation has false conclusions (conspiracy theories ,now about Pakistan Intelligence ) because we do not want to read or pursue facts.Like people prefer to be spoon fed by Geo what is happening instead of observing or analysing the situation,reading the editorials.
This is beyond my comprehension why Pakistani people hate its own army so much?Now after Army I feel there is this mistrust about our Intelligence institution.
Half of the nation thought Bhotto and Benazir were agents of America now Pervaiz Musharaff is agent of America……….
What ever happens in Pakistan it is the shared and equal responsibility of Civil and Military government but to blame all the Martial laws and Political decions on one is not acceptable.
Untill civilian governments understand that they cannot compromise the defence of Pakistan and they have to keep the interest of defence of country first on their agenda ,Pakistan cannot have democracy.
I am not an Army person neither related to one.I am a civilian who has been brought up to be a writer or a poet ,Benazir was my Leader ……..and I have lived through the Martial Law of Gen Zia but all of this does not mean we should not open our eyes,change our openion and give people chance,give ourself a chance……
Education means nothing and nor does freedom if we cannot free our minds and imagination.
We are in 21 century but are doing politics of Quaid-e-Azam where Iqbal had teh dream and Quaid-e-Azam got it for us ,people only followed with the help of few more leaders.
People of Pakistan please understand DEMOCRACY MEANS EVERYONE HAS A RESPONSIBILITY ,EVERYONE HAS A SAY ,EVERYONE HAS TO SHARE RESPONSIBILITY,CAN WE STOP BLAMING EACHOTHER………………..
My question to the people of Pakistan is ,what is the way forward from here???????
By: Ms. Shah on August 21, 2008
at 9:07 am
Half of the Nation thinks ,Musharaff is too much pro American,
Followers of Bhotto clan think Shriefs are most corrupt and should not be in the politics,
Shrief supporters feel in the same way about Bhotto and instead of focusing on ideas we focus on personalities.
The worst slavery I have seen in the world is in Pakistan.I know why I appreciated Mr.Bhutto for his democracy education and raising upto uniting Islamic world leaders,
Benazir because she was dedicated to the cause of bringing democracy in the country and because she was a woman and because she had to put up with Zardari………..
I do not understand why people are now waiting for Bilawal to come to take over?Why he is so young,he has to learn,he has to experience world,he has to develop vision,what until than?
The whole nation will be sitting and wait for the contest between Shrief and Bhottos inheritors?
So bizare ,so out of date…………….
Why ordinary people cannot be the politicians ,why a bus driver ,school teacher or university professor lead the nation?????
WHy we cannot respect a soldier ,a police officer or a politician or a civil servant or a judge………..
we do not respect ourselves ?
Who is responsible for that?The pride comes from inside it cannot be bought and sold?
Can we wake up???????
By: Ms. Shah on August 21, 2008
at 9:28 am
My apology by mistake I have put politician together with a soldier ,police officer and civil service…….
People do not respect a politician and rightfully so
By: Ms. Shah on August 21, 2008
at 10:24 am